Most professionals would like to win more of the work they enjoy, are good at and can charge appropriately for. Yet many find themselves spending too much time on work they would rather not be doing, while struggling to attract the clients and assignments they really want.
Why is this so difficult?
The answer may have less to do with professional competence, technical expertise or even the quality of the service being offered than we imagine.
Decades of psychological research suggest that human beings are naturally resistant to influence. Understanding why, and what makes people more receptive, could transform the way professionals approach winning new business.
Why people resist persuasion
In 1966, psychologist Jack Brehm introduced the theory of psychological reactance. He demonstrated that when people perceive their freedom to choose is being threatened, they become motivated to resist that threat.
The more someone feels they are being persuaded, the more determined they may become to make up their own mind.
This presents a particular challenge for professionals. They may be highly competent, have an excellent reputation and offer precisely the expertise a prospective client needs. Yet attempts to convince another professional that their client needs your services may produce resistance rather than enthusiasm.
Jonah Berger, a professor at the Wharton School and author of The Catalyst: How to Change Anyone's Mind, develops this argument. Rather than pushing harder to persuade people, he suggests identifying and removing the barriers that prevent them from changing their minds.
Perhaps the answer is not to become more persuasive, but to create circumstances in which persuasion becomes less necessary.
Why familiarity and trust matter
Robert Cialdini, author of Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, identified several principles that help explain why people respond positively to certain individuals and situations.
Among these are authority, liking and social proof. We are more receptive to people we trust, whose expertise we recognise and whose credibility is reinforced by others.
This helps explain why personal recommendations remain so important in professional services.
Yet many professionals know surprisingly little about what their own colleagues do for their clients, let alone the professionals they meet outside their firms.
Why, when cross-referrals offer such obvious opportunities, are they so difficult to generate?
Part of the explanation may be resistance to persuasion. Being told repeatedly what colleagues do, or encouraged to introduce them to clients, can feel like another demand on already busy professionals. It may provoke resistance rather than curiosity.
There is also the question of confidence. Would you introduce someone to an important client without really understanding their expertise or knowing how they work?
Psychologist Robert Zajonc's pioneering research into the mere-exposure effect, published in 1968, adds another dimension. He demonstrated that repeated exposure to a stimulus can, under appropriate conditions, increase positive feelings towards it.
Familiarity alone does not establish competence or guarantee trust. Nevertheless, repeated, positive contact can make professional relationships easier to develop.
The importance of relationships
Malcolm Gladwell, in The Tipping Point, explored how ideas and behaviours spread through networks of social connections.
His work highlights the importance of relationships in bringing people and ideas together.
Consider a client contemplating the sale of a business. They may need lawyers, accountants, investment advisers, tax specialists and wealth managers.
Each may have considerable expertise, yet the client may know only one or two of them.
The opportunity for the others depends not simply on their competence, but on whether the advisers already trusted by the client know them, understand what they do and feel confident introducing them.
And that confidence rarely comes from listening to another presentation about someone's expertise.
It is more likely to develop when professionals have opportunities to explore real client situations together and discover, for themselves, how their different skills can contribute.
Putting the psychology to work
What happens if we bring these five strands of psychological research together?
Brehm and Berger help explain why trying harder to persuade people may be counterproductive. Cialdini explains the importance of trust and credibility. Zajonc demonstrates the potential value of familiarity, while Gladwell draws attention to the networks through which relationships and ideas spread.
Together, they suggest a different approach to winning professional work.
One that begins not with selling, but with understanding the clients and assignments professionals really want, identifying who already knows and advises those clients, and creating opportunities for the relevant professionals to work through client situations together.
This is the thinking behind ClientCentric, the programme developed by Caroline's Club to help professionals win more of the work they want from the clients they want to work with.
Rather than relying on isolated networking events or presentations, ClientCentric brings professionals together as members of a club around client scenarios in a structured, repeatable process. Participants discover what others can contribute, develop familiarity and confidence, and identify opportunities to collaborate and make introductions.
The process can be repeated within firms, between professionals from different disciplines and, ultimately, with clients themselves.
The objective is not to persuade people to make referrals. It is to create the circumstances in which they have good reasons to want to.
Winning better-quality business should not depend on becoming a better salesperson. It should begin with making it easier for the right people to understand, trust and recommend one another.
If you would like to explore how ClientCentric could work for your firm, please send me a message.